Leadership Thoughts

Leadership hiring when markets are in upheaval

26 August 2026 · Alex Beutler

When a shock hits a market, hiring is often one of the first things to be stopped. I have seen it in downturns, in financing crunches, and in those sudden periods when boards want every discretionary cost off the table. If a business is genuinely short of cash, a freeze can be a rational decision. If the business is still trying to grow, or to get a metals asset ready for its next phase, it is often a lost opportunity.

Upheaval changes the employment market in ways that are easy to misread. Demand for people drops in some businesses. Contract and consulting work, which in more ordinary times holds a number of very capable specialists and leaders, is often among the first things to be cut. Other organisations reduce hours, or make people redundant, including people who were not the problem. The result is a temporary improvement in supply: not because the pool of proven metals leaders has suddenly grown, but because more of those people will take a conversation than they would have a year earlier.

What the window actually is

I would be careful with how that window is used. This is not an argument for picking people up cheaply, or for treating a difficult period as a chance to talk someone into a lesser job. Proven people may be more open. They have not become less discerning, and they will remember how they were treated. The opportunity is to reach people who were not reachable in a tighter market, and to do so fairly, with a clear brief and a coherent package.

Some of those people will have been caught in the wrong business, at the wrong time, in the wrong place. Outstanding leaders in unemployment are still uncommon. What is less uncommon, in a shock, is a strong person who would not have taken a call six months earlier and will take one now. In my experience, people who are given a serious opportunity in a difficult period often show a deeper loyalty to the business that hired them than people who move in a more buoyant market. That is not a rule. It is something I have seen often enough to take seriously.

There is a second use of the same window that boards sometimes miss. The point is not only to fill seats that are already vacant. It can also be the moment to strengthen a role that was filled poorly when the market was tight and the same few operators were being pulled in every direction. A shock is an unwelcome event. It can still be the first chance in some time to put the right person into a job that has been carrying a compromise.

The same instinct that is useful when assets come onto the market in a crisis is useful here. Shrewd boards look carefully at what has become available. They do not assume that every name now in circulation is a fit, and they do not stop looking just because the organisation around them has gone quiet.

How to use a difficult period well

A proper process still matters, perhaps more than it does when everyone is busy. A clearer market is not the same as an easy one. You still need to be honest about the phase of the asset, the accountabilities in the role, and what "good" looks like. You still need to map the field, approach people confidentially, and take references seriously. Some of the people who are suddenly available will be available for good reason. Some will be exactly the appointment you could not get near in the last upswing.

Leadership Consulting, in this kind of period, is often about helping a board decide which seats actually matter for the next twelve or eighteen months, and which appointments can wait. Executive search is how you then use the window: not as a scramble, and not as a freeze, but as a deliberate look at people who are now willing to talk.

The businesses that come out of upheaval with a stronger leadership team are usually the ones that kept thinking about the work ahead, rather than only about the cost in front of them. High-performing teams are not built by waiting until conditions feel comfortable again. They are built by being clear about the people you need, and by being willing to have those conversations when others have stopped.

← All insights

The Rock People perspective

Subscribe to Leadership Thoughts

Leadership moves, market news and our thinking on mining leadership.

Let’s start a conversation

Let’s explore
what’s next.

Looking for your next leader, or your next chapter? Tell us what’s on your horizon. Every conversation is confidential.

LinkedIn profile (optional)