Attracting proven leaders who are not looking
19 August 2026 · Alex Beutler
I still see job advertisements that make me wince. It is not because a competitor, or an internal team, has a brief that is not mine. It is because the purpose of the communication has been missed. The point of a serious approach, or of an advertisement if you are going to run one, is to attract the best person for the job. Too often, what is published is a job description with a logo on top.
A job specification, a job description and an advertisement are called different things because they do different work. A specification is for the process. It can be long, precise and internal. An advertisement, if you use one, should give a short, honest picture of the role, the asset, the location, the travel, and what is genuinely distinctive about the opportunity, and it should make a suitable person want to have a conversation. A shopping list copied out of a job description will not keep a strong reader with you. It will certainly not move the people you most want.
The people you want are usually not looking
That last point is the one I would hold onto. In the leadership work I do, the people who have actually led a study, a build, an operation or an exploration effort through its next phase are usually already in a role. They are not scrolling job boards of an evening. They expect the next conversation to be put to them, confidentially, by someone who understands the work and can explain why this particular job is worth their time.
You do not need to decorate the truth to do that well. You should not undersell the brief either. If the asset has a real story, if the board is a good one to work with, if the role has unusual scope or a genuine path to the next phase of the project, that should be said plainly. If the job involves hard travel, a tight timetable, or a turnaround rather than a clean build, that should be said plainly too. Proven people can live with difficulty. They do not respond well to a proposition that has been flattened into generic language, or to one that hides the parts of the job that will actually shape their week.
When a weak approach looks as if it worked
A poor advertisement, or a casual approach, has a further problem that is easy to miss in a quieter market. You may still get responses. Some of them will be perfectly decent. It is possible to shortlist from that pile and believe the process has done its job. What you have not done is reached the people who were never going to answer an advertisement, and who would have changed the quality of the outcome.
That is not a small gap. It is the difference between hiring from those who happen to be looking, and hiring from those who can actually do the work. The second group has to be attracted. They will take a call if the approach is serious, the brief is clear, and the conversation is discreet. They will not do your job for you by finding a poorly written advertisement and deciding it is aimed at them.
What a serious approach requires
If I am honest, most of the strongest appointments I am involved in do not begin with an advertisement at all. They begin with a clear brief, a mapped market, and a direct approach to a small number of people who fit the work. That is executive search. The advertisement, when it is used, is a complement, not the method.
Around that sits Leadership Consulting: getting the role, the accountabilities and the proposition right before anyone is approached. If the job is still a compromise between several needs, or if the board has not yet agreed what "good" looks like for this phase of the asset, no amount of polished language will repair it. Attraction starts with an honest brief. It is then a matter of putting that brief, clearly and respectfully, to the right people.
The businesses that do this well do not wait for proven leaders to come and find them. They decide who they need, they look properly at who is actually in the market, and they make an approach that is worthy of the person they are asking to move. That is slower than posting a description and seeing what arrives. It is also how you reach people who are not looking, which is where most of the leadership talent in this industry sits.