Leadership Thoughts

The cost of a leadership mis-hire, and what a good hire looks like

12 August 2026 · Alex Beutler

I am often asked what a good hire actually is. The honest answer is that it depends whose side of the table you are sitting on, but it is not a complicated idea. A good appointment is one that works properly for the business and for the person. Filling the seat, and finding someone who looks right on paper, is only the start.

It is easy to treat a leadership search as a box-ticking exercise. Titles, years and jurisdictions matter. They are not the whole of the job. In metals, a good hire is someone who can do the work of this phase of the asset, who fits the way the board and the team actually work, and who stays long enough to see that work through. I would measure it across performance in the role, organisational fit, and tenure.

What good looks like

Performance, at this level, is not activity. It is whether a study holds up, a construction program is led with its risks visible, an operation is steadied, or an exploration effort is given a coherent plan. Fit is whether that person strengthens the culture: how they work with the board, develop the people around them, and raise the standard of the place. Tenure is the unfashionable measure, and I still think it is essential: seeing a contract through, or staying in a permanent seat long enough to matter, which in practice is measured in years.

There is a further point that is easy to miss when a board is under pressure to appoint. Strong people need to be properly challenged, or they will move. Appointing someone who can do the job, then leaving them in a smaller role than the one you described, is one of the more reliable ways to undo a good hire.

The other side of the bargain matters just as much. For a person who needs a job, any credible role can look like a success. For a proven leader with options, the test is whether this is the right next role: the quality of the asset and the board, the challenge, the location and the travel, and a coherent package. If only one side of that bargain is satisfied, tenure usually suffers. You have not made a good hire. You have made a temporary one.

What a miss actually costs

The cost of getting this wrong, at executive and senior technical level, is not the fee on a search. It is the year you lose on a study, a build, a permitting program or a relationship with the board and the financiers. It is the disruption of running a second process, and of asking a team to work under a leader who was never quite right for the phase the project is in. Those costs rarely appear on a single invoice, so they get underestimated.

A quieter market can make the mistake easier to hide at the start. More experienced people are open to a conversation, and a seat can be filled more quickly than it could have been a year earlier. That is not the same as having found the right person. Some of those appointments will leave when conditions improve, unless the role, the fit and the challenge were genuine in the first place.

Why the familiar is not a strategy

One of the more common ways a miss, or a merely adequate appointment, happens is also one of the most understandable. Boards and leadership teams hire people they already know. In my experience they do it for three reasons: trust, ease and comfort. They have history with the person. It is quicker than testing the market. The known feels safer than the unknown, even when that history is older than people like to admit.

Sometimes the person you know is the right appointment. I have no argument with a board that has already found the leader it needs and has done the work to confirm it. The problem is when that route is chosen so that a proper look at the market can be avoided. You may be depriving yourself of a stronger appointment, or assembling a team that is more familiar than it is well suited to the next phase of the asset. People you have worked with before can be excellent. They are not, by definition, the best people available for this job.

Starting with a clear objective

Before a process begins, it is worth being honest about the hiring objective. What does good look like for this asset, at this stage? What would a miss cost? Are you prepared to look beyond the names already in the room?

That is the work of Leadership Consulting as I practise it: getting the shape of the role, the accountabilities and the proposition clear, before anyone is approached. Executive search is how you then test the market, including people who are not already in the inner circle, and people who are not looking. A clear brief, a mapped market, structured conversations and references taken seriously will not make a miss impossible. They make it much harder to appoint someone only because they were close at hand.

Your next leadership appointment can add more to a business than simply getting the job done. It will only do that if you are clear about what good is, and willing to look properly for it.

← All insights

The Rock People perspective

Subscribe to Leadership Thoughts

Leadership moves, market news and our thinking on mining leadership.

Let’s start a conversation

Let’s explore
what’s next.

Looking for your next leader, or your next chapter? Tell us what’s on your horizon. Every conversation is confidential.

LinkedIn profile (optional)